Beyond the Authoritarian Wall

In order to proceed beyond the Authoritarian wall that has so well blocked our progress for thousands of years toward reaching our potential let's carefully consider a quote from James C Scott's Preface for Two Cheers of Anarchism, and use inductive reasoning to imagine that all arguments against proceeding beyond the Authoritarian wall will be more or less closely related to this one, and to imagine a way beyond the wall constructed by the thinking represented in this quote, and thereby imagine a way beyond the Authoritarian wall itself. Consider the quote now:

"What is clear to anyone except a market fundamentalist is that democracy is a cruel hoax without relative equality. This, of course, is the great dilemma for an anarchist. If relative equality is a necessary condition of mutuality and freedom, how can it be guaranteed except through the state? Facing this conundrum, I believe that both theoretically and practically, the abolition of the state is not an option. We are stuck, alas, with Leviathan, though not at all for the reasons Hobbes had supposed, and the challenge is to tame it. That challenge may well be beyond our reach."

We can all imagine the fear of the unknown in the disruption of our life support structures. But we can all see also the feasibility in our replacing the state by guaranteeing for ourselves everything we need when we redirect our faith/hope/trust away from authoritarian philosophies and institutions and toward humanity, i.e. toward our very own selves. We imagine the people, all people, or a practical majority, participating meaningfully in replacing the state in the role depicted in Scott's quote, to guarantee for ourselves relative equality as the necessary condition of mutuality and freedom. We realize we don't want a guarantee that isn't achieved by universal participation because equality must be, like everything else, via free will choice and action of the individual.

So we work together in cooperation to satisfy Scott's concern here for a guarantee of relative equality, and to satisfy all concerns and conditions toward replacing authoritarianism with anarchism. It is natural law that we each participate in providing what we are to enjoy. Natural law requires each to reach our potential in performance in order for each to reach our potential in benefits, because benefit is only real when the outcome of our own performance, whether direct or indirect, and by free will. Natural law's requirement is not that we each perform to some absolute or relative level of performance, but rather only to our own personal peak potential. The idea that some benevolent authority can surpass the potential of humanity in serving ourselves is as foolish and ridiculous as the idea of humanity conquering nature.

Anarchism versus Authoritarianism

Anarchism and Authoritarianism are two opposing ideals. Anarchism asserts that maximized, balanced equality and autonomy among people is natural while authoritarianism either asserts this to be unnatural, or wholly/partially denies its relevance, or only pretends its relevance.

The outcomes are that we meet our universal human needs with least work/cost/harm, i.e. reach maximum universal wellbeing, when practicing anarchism, while we create mountains of misguided strategies to meet needs, with catastrophic results, when practicing authoritarianism. The explanation for these opposing outcomes is that anarchism recognizes the truth about human nature while authoritarianism denies this truth.

The following dichotomy list details the difference between anarchism and authoritarianism. When we are able to make the connections in our minds between items in the anarchism column, and make connections in our minds between items in the authoritarianism column, and keep the two columns separate in our mind, we reach tremnedous clarity and capability to choose in support of either ideal, in all our daily activities. When we individually learn to choose positive over negative consistently then predictably entire communities, societies, and eventually the whole world can reach maximum universal wellbeing.

Philosophy Anarchism Authoritarianism
Direction
Our most important choice.
Positive
Direction of minimum work/cost/harm and maximum universal wellbeing.
Negative
All other directions.
Harm Zero Non-Zero
Help 100% Not 100%
Attitude
toward life
Optimism
powers virtuous circles
Pessimism
powers vicious circles
Honesty
Yes
relies on verifiable truths
No
relies on false claims
Outcomes Helpful Harmful
Corruption Rejected Accepted
Faith/Hope/Trust In Humanity Authority
Breeds Hope Despair
Source of Motivation Internal External
Practices Serving Life & Meeting Universal Human Needs Domination/Exploitation
Domination Strategies None Fault/Blame
Guilt/Shame
Accusations/Apologies
Strategies to Meet Needs Natural Aspirations
Giving/Sharing
Minimizing Work/Cost/Harm
Rewards/Punishments
Discipline/Rights
Duties/Obligations
Distractions None Labels/Judgments
Assumptions/Expectations
Justice/Fairness
Prime Motivators Heart Aspirations Ego Ambitions
Resources Shared Hoarded
Information Revealed Concealed
Knowledge Shared Secret
Occupations/Skills Generalized
Helpful
values/views/relations.
Specialized
Harmful
values/views/relations.
Production Localized Globalized
Providence Nature Authority
Nature Preserved Plundered
Agenda Solidarity Domination
Power Distributed Concentrated
Wellbeing Universal Privileged
Consideration Inclusive Exclusive
Vision Clear Confused
Ideas Connected Fragmented
Relations United Divided
Lifestyle Simplified Complicated
Societal System Simple Complex
Interaction Cooperative
Assertive
Confident
Competitive
Aggressive
Arrogant
Work Minimized Maximized
Consumption Minimized Maximized
Commerce
The amount of commerce is inversely proportional the wellbeing of people.
Minimized
Minimizing commerce enhances wellbeing.
Maximized
Maximizing commerce diminishes wellbeing.
Dependence Interdependence Codependence
Campfire Make Small/Sit Close Make Big/Stand Far
Earth/Life Respect/Serve Disrespect/Exploit
Serve Life Empire
Change Permanent/Stable Temporary/Unstable
Stability
High
Refinements of best practices guided by natural law
Low
Cyclic rise/fall of markets/empires
Analysis
A vital difference:
Observation
Non-controversial facts encourage consensus.
Evaluation
Controversial judgments inflame conflict.
Solicitation Request Demand
Associations
mental
Coherent
separate harmless & harmful ideas
Incoherent
mix harmless & harmful ideas
Connections
conceptual
Consistent
separate harmless & harmful things
Inconsistent
mix harmless & harmful things
Healthcare Prevention Intervention
Love Unconditional Conditional
Anarchian Glossary

Universe - Everything that exists that can be conceived as a whole.

Nature - Everything in our universe that we more directly experience, in particular our Earth ecosystem.

Natural Law - Causality and constraints that determine how our universe operates, either with total predictability or quantifiable probability. Natural law is universally verifiable directly through the senses by observation or experimentation.

Life - Matter's organization of itself into living organisms, driven by the life force.

Life Force - Force transformed from energy and expressed by life toward perpetuating itself.

Life Potential - The peak of life's capacity to thrive.

Life Need - A requirement necessary for life to perpetuate itself. The quantity of available resources applied to such requirements are in balance at all times when life is perpetuating itself at its potential.

Life Purpose - Natural law programming of an organism to participate in nature's order-building process, to serve life, to thrive, to reach its potential, e.g. for a bird to fly, for a fish to swim.

Harmonizing - Collectively pursuing least-cost strategies to meet universal needs.

Human Nature - Natural law regarding humanity, including not only how we work/behave but also what our needs are and what strategies meet these with least work/cost/harm. Human Nature in depth.

Human Potential - The peak of humanity's capacity to thrive.

Human Need - A requirement necessary for humanity to reach its potential. A basic account of universal human needs include, in order of priority: food/shelter, safety, love/belonging, esteem/respect, and actualization (reaching our potental).

Human Purpose - Natural law programming of a person to serve life, in order to thrive, to actualize, to reach human potential.

Priority - A placement in a list of needs ordered by a least work/cost/harm fulfillment strategy.

Free Will - The ability to think, choose and act restricted not by will, but only by natural law. A universal life need.

Ethics - Gaining gratification from the perception of universal consensus and cooperation toward the maximum thriving of life.

Reason - Expanding conceptual/categorical knowledge by executing induction/deduction processes on observational inputs.

Safety - An absence of harm. A universal life need.

Equality - An absence of restrictions placed on the potential to meet one's needs.

Autonomy - An absence of restrictions placed on the process of meeting one's needs.

Emotion - A lower level response occurring in the subcortical regions of the brain, the amygdala, and the ventromedial prefrontal cortices, creating biochemical reactions in the body altering its physical state. An emotion in animals produces a quick reaction to environmental stimuli for survival purposes and is genetially encoded with only slight variations among individuals and significant similarities in many species. *

Feeling - A higher level response originating in the neocortical regions of the brain, and is a mental association and reaction to emotions, and is subjective being influenced by personal experience, beliefs, and memories. A feeling is a mental portrayal of what is going on in your body when you have an emotion and is the byproduct of your brain perceiving and assigning meaning to the emotion. *

Fear - An emotion triggered by a perceived threat to one's wellbeing and a judgment that the only recourse is to flee to distance the threat, and that raises physical strength and mental focus to achieve this objective.

Anger - An emotion triggered by a perceived threat to one's wellbeing and a judgment that the only recourse is to fight to eliminate the threat, and that raises physical strength and mental focus to achieve this objective.

Humility - Authoritarian feeling of appreciation in others or comparison with one's self, i.e. subconscious thought recognizing the competence of others for the purpose of mitigating guilt or countering hubris, in a way that unwittingly preserves while pretending to counter authoritarian worldviews/practices.

Deduction - Applying logic from a general case to a special case, i.e. utilizing a theory.

Induction - Applying logic from a special case to a general case, i.e. forming a theory.

Faith - A belief in something that competes with ethics and reason to influence thoughts, choices and actions.

Hope - A wanting for something that competes with ethics and reason to influence thoughts, choices and actions.

Trust - A belief in someone that competes with ethics and reason to influence thoughts, choices and actions.

Heart - The source of aspirations (anticipation gratifications) within us seeking to maximize universal wellbeing.

Ego - The source of ambitions (anticipation gratifications) within us seeking to achieve personal wellbeing at the expense of others.

Violence - Physical, mental, or spiritual activity that harms, usually motivated by anger.

Help/Harm - Order construction/desctruction.

Process - A procedure of help/harm, refined and repeated as needed to sustain a predictable outcome. A process takes input and gives output according to a formula, for example a decision results from processing current conditions with a given theoretical model. A process may be carried out mentally or physically, by an individual, group, ecosystem, or universe.

Entropy - The process of desconstruction of order.

Feedback - The outcome of a process feeding back into the process, amplifying the outcome. With multiple processes in a feedback loop, outcomes are maximum when equal, like a rectangle area is maximum with sides equal (square). Amplification provides for a rate of order-building to meet and exceed the natural rate of entropy.

Vicious Circle - Multiplying of negativity in thoughts, choices, and actions by frequent repetition, producing habituation/conditioning, increasing probabilities of future negativity.

Virtuous Circle - Multiplying of positivity in thoughts, choices, and actions by frequent repetition, producing habituation/conditioning, increasing probabilities of future positivity.

Value - Total benefit per total cost.

Frame - Subconscious priorities, underlying a conscious observation, giving it meaning. Exercise: Try to identify the difference between this definition and Wikipedia's and explore potential benefits of the anarchian definition: Wikipedia - In the social sciences, a frame comprises a set of concepts and theoretical perspectives on how individuals, groups, and societies, organize, perceive, and communicate about reality.

Gratification - The pleasure experienced from anticipating or manifesting the meeting of a need, and the physiological motivator to serve life, i.e. to participate in nature's order-building.

Anticipation Gratification - The pleasure experienced from visualizing a gratification that compels a pursuit to meet a need.

Manifestation Gratification - The pleasure experienced from manifesting the completion of meeting a need.

Habit - A learned/conditioned thought/action response, regularly/reliably triggered by external/internal stimulus.

Learning - Causing a stimulus to reliably trigger an anticipation gratification by associating it with a manifestation gratification.

Conditioning - Causing a stimulus to reliably trigger an anticipation gratification by associating it with another stimulus that already does so.

Authoritarian Glossary

Duty

Obligation

Reward

Punushment

Label

Judgment

Fault

Blame

Guilt

Shame

Earn

Deserve

Grade/Fair/Even/Score/Best/Worst/Win/Lose

Original Sin

Be